Judicial plan harming Israeli economy, causing polarization: S&P
Protesters hold Israeli flags as they demonstrate following a parliament vote on a contested bill that limits Supreme Court powers to void some government decisions, near the Knesset, West Jerusalem, Israel, July 24, 2023. (Reuters Photo)


Israel's plans to curtail certain powers of the Supreme Court and the ongoing controversy are causing a growing domestic political uncertainty and are expected to result in reduced economic growth this year, S&P Global Ratings said in a country report on Thursday.

S&P did not take any ratings action on Israel. In May it affirmed its "AA-/A-1+" credit rating and stable outlook. Its next ratings review is scheduled for Nov. 10

The plans being pursued by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his right-wing government have prompted months of unprecedented protests, opened up a deep divide in Israeli society, and strained the loyalties of some army reservists.

It has also spooked foreign investors and led to a more than 8% depreciation of the shekel in the past six months.

"If government and opposition do not achieve an agreement on the topic, this could further exacerbate domestic political confrontation and weigh on medium-term economic growth," S&P said.

In the short term, it projects Israel's economic growth to slow to 1.5% this year from 6.5% in 2022, citing the persisting political uncertainty that will combine with weaker economic performance in Israel's key trading partners in Europe and the United States as well as tighter monetary policy.

S&P's report followed a similar warning issued by Moody's rating agency on Tuesday.

"We consider that domestic political polarization and volatility in Israel will remain high in the coming months," it said, noting that for now, "the prospects for adoption of other parts of the judicial reform remain unclear."

Political watchdog groups have appealed to the Supreme Court to overturn a new law passed by parliament in the first of the changes to trim Supreme Court powers, paving the way to a showdown among branches of government when it hears the arguments in September.

S&P said that its Israel ratings have in the past been consistently constrained by domestic and regional political and security risks. Israel, it added, has a history of frequent elections and changes in government composition which makes future policy direction harder to predict.

Still, it said, "we do not expect local political or regional tensions to escalate into more significant domestic confrontation or a sustained armed conflict in Gaza or the West Bank."

S&P said Israel's credit strengths include its wealthy and diversified economy and its net external asset position.